So, I finally saw Black Panther. First off, let me say, Marvel superheroes are not my favorites–I’m more of a DC person. Other than Guardians of the Galaxy and The Avengers movies, I really haven’t seen most of them–I don’t care for most of the characters. (Except Deadpool, but how can you not love Deadpool?) So, already, there is a lack of “OH MY GOD, THIS IS THE BEST THING EVER!” That being said, I do still enjoy the ones I see, and in general, I find them entertaining and will generally watch them more than once.
I decided to watch it before Oscar night because I was concerned that if it won, it would be a purely political thing, and in the event that happened, I wanted to be able to have an informed opinion.
First, what I liked about it. The costumes were stunning. Vibrant, lush and celebratory of African culture. A well-deserved Oscar win. The art direction was also stunning-every detail was checked and consistent. Another well-deserved Oscar win. The acting was strong–not the best, but quality. Michael B. Jordan impressed me the most–I thoroughly enjoyed his character of Killmonger.
Other than that–meh. Here’s what bothers me? First, why do Wakandians have English accents? African people have European accents because of the countries which colonized them. So, if Wakanda has been isolated forever, why do they have English accents? Is it because the English accent sounds more refined, more intelligent? Is it to set them apart from the brutal non-Wakandians? Killmonger does not have an accent,which makes sense, he’s American. But his father did, at least he does in the flashback. If children are exposed to an accent, they generally will speak that way–there are children who are not English all over the world who speak like Peppa Pig, so we know this is a fact. But the child we see in the flashback does not have an accent. So, his father consciously made an effort for every moment of his life to maintain his American accent, even in the comfort of his own home? Is it because he wouldn’t fit into the thug life that he was apparently sent to observe? Wouldn’t it make more sense to have them speak in Wakandian (which there clearly is since they show it in writing) and use subtitles, much like Lord of the Rings?
Second, T’Challa is a wimp. He needs a suit and a supernatural root to be strong and fight. His royal guard, all women, fight and win with just a spear. Okoye (is that her name?) does half the car chase with no armor and just a spear and takes out so many. Let her run the kingdom. And frankly, if the women are so strong, why have they not overthrown the patriarchal society that they are beholden to and run Wakanda themselves? Like most societies, they are anyway, just not acknowledged.
Third, the Wakandians control all the technology. The tribes that exist around them support them and fight for them, but they live in huts on the savannah. That sounds like European colonization all over again.
Fourth, where’s the loyalty? As soon as Killmonger goes to fight, everyone who was so against him becoming king rush off to fight for him, except the Royal Guard. “Oh, you killed our beloved king, you horrible outsider! Wait, we’ll fight with you against him!” Was T’Challa really that bad a king?
Fifth, if Wakanda is sending spies all over the world, why didn’t they actually try to make the world a better place, instead of start a violent uprising? Why not send out more Martin Luther King’s or Rosa Parks or great African-Americans? Why more thugs?
And maybe I missed this, but if no one knows about Wakanda, why were they at that meeting where T’Challa’s father is killed? And clearly, someone somewhere knows about vibranium, since Captain’s shield is made out of it. No one sees the ships landing to bring the spies? Really, no one knows.
In all it’s not a bad movie, and it has entertainment value, but it’s not the beacon of hope for African-Americans that people want it to be.
How about we stop separating and just talk about a good superhero movie, not a good black superhero movie?